29 3. (a) when any allegation that could reasonably constitute abuse or 30 neglect is received by the register, the register shall accept and immediately transmit notice of the report orally or electronically to the appropriate state oversight agency and, as appropriate, to the director or operator of that facility or provider agency. (i) upon acceptance of a report of abuse or neglect by the vulnerable persons’ central register, promptly commence an appropriate investigation;
I know it looks as if I were against everything, but that is not the case. It’s difficult for people who have been entangled in the bureaucratic web while trying to resolve problems with it to not recognize the problems that these ‘new solutions’ create. Case in point, the above quote from the BILL 7400.
This new bill eliminated the Commission on Quality of Care because the commission was doing nothing. The commission would receive complains and dismiss them as ‘not reasonably constituting abuse’. By their own account in 2011, out of a bit less than 10k complains, they “screened” only 250. That means that they found the other 9k plus complains to be ‘not reasonably constituting” abuse. Yet, the commission was eliminated because there was abuse and they did nothing meaningful, they even didn’t include the cases denounced by the NY Times because those cases were in ‘not licensed’ programs and not licensed programs were not part of the commission’ surveys.
So now a clerk is going to receive some complains over the phone and make a decision right then and there that the complain “reasonably constitute abuse”. Then “(i) upon acceptance of a report of abuse or neglect by the vulnerable persons’ central register, promptly commence an appropriate investigation;”. That means that if they don’t accept the report, nothing will happen.
Think: do you have any idea of how difficult it has been for LAWYERS to convince JUDGES in civil court that an act constituted abuse? The Justice Center came as a result of the inability of our courts to protect these people. A whole agency (CQCA) was banished for doing a terrible job, but some how A CLERK OVER THE PHONE WILL DO A BETTER JOB AT ASSESSING THAT A REPORT CONSTITUTE ABUSE!. I’m not screaming, I’m just highlighting!
I just don’t see it, how is this bill any better at preventing abuse. I’m waiting to get someone to enlighten me.